The demise of longwave could lead to the end of the Shipping Forecast

shipping-forecast-locations

Many thanks to SWLing Post reader, Erica, who writes:

“I saw this article about the demise of the Shipping Forecast on Radio 4 Longwave and thought readers might be interested:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/bbc/11892805/End-of-Shipping-Forecast-on-long-wave-radio-could-leave-sailors-high-and-dry.html

I’m not a fan of DAB radio and my bedroom radio aerial has to be positioned just so to get radio 4 FM with cclarity, so I will be disappointed if Longwave eventually gets switched off. That’s not to mention all the people–however many there may be–who don’t have easy ways to get weather info out at sea.”

Here’s an excerpt from The Telegraph:

It has kept sailors safe on the ocean waves for 90 years, becoming just as much a part of national consciousness as cricket, cups of tea and The Archers.

But the days of hearing the Shipping Forecast out on a boat may be numbered thanks to the demise of long wave technology, a veteran announcer has said.

Peter Jefferson, who read the Shipping Forecast to Radio 4 listeners for 40 years, said the “very old” transmitters which worked on long wave could soon be retired.

If that was to happen, he said, anyone more than 12 miles from the coastline would be unable to hear the shipping forecast on long wave, ending a Radio 4 tradition dating back to 1924.

Speaking at the Radio Times Festival, in Hampton Court, Mr Jefferson said the soothing tones of the Shipping Forecast would then be left to its many fans who choose to listen to it from their homes in lieu of a “sleeping pill”.

“Long wave reaches much further than FM, it’s as simple as that,” he said.
“So FM would be totally useless for shipping beyond 12 miles from land.

[…]A spokesman for the BBC said they were no firm plans to end long wave broadcasting, and no date set for when the technology could run out.

The service currently reaches as far as south-east Iceland, and is occasionally picked up as far as 3,000 miles away.

Read this full article at The Telegraph online.

Of course, I haven’t heard the Shipping Forecast on longwave since moving back to the States from the UK. Still, I would be very sad to hear the program and the longwave medium fall silent.

I would like to start adding some Shipping Forecast programs on the Shortwave Radio Audio Archive where we also curate select mediumwave and longwave recordings.  If you have the means to record episodes on longwave, please consider helping us!

Spread the radio love

12 thoughts on “The demise of longwave could lead to the end of the Shipping Forecast

  1. Richard Langley

    Shutting down the BBC Radio 4 LW transmitter on 198 kHz might also affect how the U.K. responds to a nuclear attack. According to a recent article in The Guardian:

    “[Labour leader Jeremy] Corbyn has suggested he would decline to authorise the use of Trident in the two circumstances envisaged under the arrangements in place since the cold war.

    “In the first instance, based on the assumption that the UK is still a functioning state, the chief of the defence staff recommends to the prime minister that nuclear weapons should be launched from a Vanguard-class submarine, one of which is always on patrol. An attack could not be launched without the prime minister’s authorisation.

    “The second instance is based on the assumption that the UK is no longer a functioning state. In such circumstances, signalled when BBC Radio 4 can no longer be heard, the commander of the submarine on patrol would take out [a] sealed letter from a safe, written by the prime minister, instructing them on what to do.”

    Presumably, it is the Droitwich Radio 4 LW transmitter that is referred to as a submarine could be from from coastal areas where FM and DAB broadcasts might not reach. The German international media scene blog DXaktuell.de has also noted this potential scenario:
    http://www.dxaktuell.de/2015/10/wenn-droitwich-funkt-lebt-grossbritannien/

    Reply
  2. Richard Langley

    Also, to be clear, the Shipping Forecast isn’t only transmitted on LW. There are four forecasts each day at 00:48, 05:20, 12:01, and 17:54 local time. Only the 12:01 version is broadcast only on LW. The 17:54 version is transmitted only on LW on weekdays but on the weekend it is transmitted on both FM and LW. The other two, including the late-night version, are broadcast on both FM and LW.

    But, if Radio 4 LW were to be shut down and no other changes were made, then in addition to some Shipping Forecasts the followed would go (caution; from Wikipedia): “Yesterday In Parliament at 0835–0900 on Tuesdays to Fridays, The Daily Service at 0945–1000 on Mondays to Fridays, the Shipping Forecast at 1201–1204 daily and 1754–1757 on Mondays to Fridays, and Test Match Special during international cricket games”.

    In addition to the live radio transmissions, the Shipping Forecasts can be heard via the Internet in the Radio 4 live streams and on demand.

    The Shipping Forecast even has its own Web page:
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b006qfvv
    The clip at
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p02ps1dm
    is quite interesting.

    The Wikipedia article on the main Radio 4 LW transmitter site at Droitwich says:
    “However, since March 2014 the BBC is doing works in the transmitter that result in a very weak signal reception in Europe. As of March 2015, the reception of BBC4 LW 198 kHz is still very poor and difficult, even in the countries next to the UK in continental Europe.” Does anyone know if the transmitter work has been completed?

    I recorded the late-night version of the Shipping Forecast last night using the SDR at the University of Twente and will submit the recording to the Shortwave Radio Audio Archive shortly.

    Reply
  3. Article inspector

    Erm, where are the facts here ?

    Nowhere does it say LW is closing down, nowhere does it say that it’s impossible
    to repair transmitters. This is another prime example of a vapourware rumour.

    Where are the facts ?

    Reply
    1. Thomas Post author

      You’re right. As quoted, “A spokesman for the BBC said they were no firm plans to end long wave broadcasting, and no date set for when the technology could run out.”

      With that said, we know the trend is for the closure of longwave and with the budget cuts the BBC are facing, it’s a real possibility. RTE and Radio France have already started the process.

      I think, however, that the British public may very well put up a fight to keep the Shipping Forecast on the air and longwave as well. This article is a case in point–a warning of what seems to be coming down the pipeline. The Shipping Forecast is such an institution and universally loved, it may survive in the long run. At least I hope so. Time will tell.

      Reply
      1. Article inspector

        I think the Telegraph was having a slow news day 😉

        It’s actually an old story floated about some time ago, in almost
        exactly the same format. I guess at least it has reminded everyone
        that BBC R4 LW still exists, an free advert for it.

        Whilst it’s true that many other LW stations have closed, they have
        been in countries where they don’t need things like shipping
        forecasts, or programming opt-outs for tennis or cricket, or
        already have other methods of providing industry teleswitching
        which R4 LW provides, as well as a frequency standard.

        So I think the UK has more of a use for it. The highlands of
        Scotland are not covered by FM too well, neither is Wales.

        But I think there could be a little more use made of some more
        alternative programming via it, to boost it’s potential.

        After all, I am as much a dx listener / radio fanatic as I am a
        general “consumer” of programming, which of course usually
        makes sense to listen on FM.

        Reply
  4. Lawrence Harris

    And not only the shipping forecast will go but also “Sailing By” too – a lovely tune to listen to on a stormy night!

    This is yet another example of BBC madness cutting off the last of our possibilities of we long-range British Radio 4 listeners in Europe. I for one really enjoy listening to Radio 4 throughout the day with its crackles and whistles filling my living room- and have done so all my life since listening on my childhood-days own-built crystal set radio. Not only does it give real, live broadcast effects, but it also lets me know of impending thunder storms as the static crackles become louder. You can’t get this “live-feeling” on the Internet.

    Shame on you BBC!

    Reply
  5. Dennis

    The BBC 4 transmission on 198 khz reaches not only Iceland, but even Moscow region as well. I love to listen to it’s faint but clear signal at late night, and yes, sometimes I use the Shipping Forecast as a sleeping pill)) What demise are they talking about? This is more than a tradition, this is one of British symbols. This will be real shame if they finish it off some day.

    Reply
    1. Thomas Post author

      Lucky you, Dennis! I wish I could hear the Shipping Forecast on LW in the States. I will give it a good go this winter–perhaps conditions will surprise me and they’ll rise above the noise floor for a few minutes.

      I’m very curious if any listeners in Newfoundland or the Maritimes can hear the ‘Forecast on longwave.

      Reply
      1. Dennis

        There’s nothing impossible for the LW and AM spread in autumn and winter time. I recently heard Turkmenistan on LW, China and Korea on Broadcast at a local station level, both are thousands miles away from my QTH. You should keep listening, Thomas, I’m pretty sure it may be heard in the States, East Coast at least.

        Reply
  6. JR

    I’ve been a fairly regular listener for many years – to Radio Four long wave in general and to the shipping forecasts in particular -, and I think it would be a mistake to leave 198 kHz. Long wave is an easy way for central Europeans to listen to voices from Britain, and just the more important since the BBC WS left 648 kHz years ago.

    If Britain wants to keep Radio Four on long wave, equipment would be available, and at fairly low prices at that. It’s a matter of what they really want, and not a matter of exotic valves.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.